14 Thoughtful Father’s Day Gifts from Etsy — All Under $35 (No Socks In Sight)
Shop the top Etsy Father’s Day gifts for new and seasoned Dads!
Skip the mug and socks this year! I’ve curated 14 of my favorite Etsy Father’s Day gift ideas that dad will truly love – and use. Plus, each one supports small creators and are all under $35 shipped!
Check out the best Etsy Father’s Day Gifts for 2025:
1. The golfing Dad in your life will love using these personalized golf tees.
Personalized Golf Tees 20-Pack from $10.98
*Shipping is $4.25 or free on orders $35+.
Grab a set of personalized golf balls to gift with these tees.
2. Dad will never forget his keys again with this adorable keychain.
Personalized Leather Keychain from $17.80 (reg. $35.60)
*Shipping is $5.80.
3. Dad will be proud to rock this shirt on Father’s Day if he has a little mini-me.
Dad and Baby Ctrl Shirts $11.65 (reg. $23.30)
*Shipping is $4.57 or free on orders $35+.
Dad and Baby Ctrl shirts are a playful nod to the fact that the apple really doesn’t fall far from the tree! With “Ctrl + C” for Dad and “Ctrl + P” for the little one, these shirts are a hilarious and adorable way to show off how much they look alike, and you’ll stay under $30 shipped even when you buy both!
4. Any grill master will love putting their stamp of approval on every dish.
Custom Food Branding Irons from $28.57 shipped (reg. $35.71)
A custom branding iron for food is a sizzling Etsy Father’s Day gift that’ll take Dad’s grill game to the next level! A customized iron with a straight handle is under $30 shipped and perfect for branding burgers, steaks, leather, wood, paper, and more.
Want to go big? Upgrade to the electric handle (up to 500W!) or a bold 4″ brand for a splurge-worthy surprise. Whether he’s stamping steaks or personalizing projects, this gift brings the heat in all the best ways!
5. The outdoorsy Dad will love this limitless personalized journal.
Personalized Leather Journal from $18.99 (reg. $37.98)
*Shipping is $4.84.
For the outdoorsy dad who loves hitting the trails or soaking up the quiet of nature, a personalized leather journal is the perfect Father’s Day gift. The best part? You’ll still be well under the $40 if you choose to personalize it, which means thoughtful and budget-friendly. Win-win!
6. Gift Dad a handsome bracelet with his family’s names on it.
Personalized Men’s Leather Bracelet from $19.80 shipped (reg. $44)
Whether he has one kiddo or seven, Dad can carry them all on this stylish, new bracelet. Plus, there’s room to add more down the road. 😉 Even better, the beads are totally customizable, so you can add special dates, crosses, or whatever else inspires him.
Shopping around? We also love this gold chain name bracelet or beaded bracelet, depending on Dad’s style.
7. This funny card will put a smile on Dad’s face.
*Shipping is $4.75 or free on orders $35+
8. The handy Dad in your life will cherish this tape measure.
Personalized Tape Measure from $22.36 shipped (reg. $27.95)
9. Grab a custom guitar pick for the Dad who seriously rocks.
Personalized Guitar Pick w/ Custom Box $14.30 shipped (reg. $35.76)
*Get the guitar pick without the box for just $7.81 shipped!
A personalized guitar pick hits all the right notes for a Father’s Day gift – thoughtful, useful, and totally unique. Whether Dad’s a seasoned strummer or just likes to pluck a few chords now and then, this custom pick adds a personal touch to his favorite hobby.
Even better? You can snag a wooden keepsake box, ready to impress, and you get to choose from 20 different designs.
10. This minimalist baseball hat is something he’ll love sporting beyond Father’s Day.
Embroidered “Cool Dad” Baseball Cap $19.75 (reg. $37)
*Shipping is $5.30.
Available in a variety of colors to match his style, this cap also onlinees with customizable thread options—and if “Cool Dad” isn’t quite his speed, you can switch up the text to say whatever fits him best.
11. Let your kiddo build a keepsake that Dad will cherish forever by answering the prompts in this book.
Hey Dad! Fill-in the Blank Book $12.80 (reg. $16)
*Shipping is $5.70 or free with orders $35+.
With 30 creative prompts, this little book turns your kids’ thoughts about Dad into pure gold. It’s the kind of keepsake Dad will actually want to keep forever.
12. Take Dad’s taste buds on a wild ride with this surprise box of exotic jerky.
Exotic Meat Stick 10-Count Variety Box $31.97 shipped
With meats like camel, venison, buffalo, elk, kangaroo, caribou, and alligator, this box is the ultimate gift for the adventurous foodie!
13. Spoil Dad and his skin with artisan beef tallow soap.
Cèdre No. 06 Tallow Bar Soap $9.50
*Shipping is $6.30 or free with orders $35+.
Cured for six weeks and wrapped in biodegradable packaging, it’s a small-batch, no-fuss luxury he’ll actually use – and love.
Want free shipping? Grab other scents and products, from beard oil to ‘stache wax and more!
14. These cut-out photos are a unique idea to show off his family at work.
Custom Photo Statuette $13.95 shipped (reg. $27.90)
