Girl Scout-Inspired Cookie Flavors You Can Get Anytime (+ Our Honest Taste Test Results!)

By Chelsey | Staff Writer
Mar 29, 2023 @ 1:30 PM MDT

As an Amazon Associate, Hip2Save earns a small onlinemission from qualifying purchases in this post. Prices and availability are accurate as of time posted. Read our full disclosure policy here.

More Grocery
25 onlinements

Get your favorite Girl Scout cookie flavors any time of the year!

similar girl scout cookie flavors on checkout line

Do you have a favorite Girl Scout cookie type?

When you just gotta have that Samoa flavor 😋 but can’t find a Girl Scout in sight or are already on your weekly ALDI trip, we’ve tested out these similar options available at popular retailers so you can get closest to the real thing when you want it!

More importantly, these Girl Scout cookie flavors are available year-round with prices starting at just $1.25! 🎉

DISCLAIMER: We love supporting girl scout members and know cookies sales are a big funding initiative. ❤️ However, if anyone is in a pinch and can’t find a seller and is craving those flavors, we’ve found generic options at multiple stores.

woman holding similar girl scout cookies flavors

What are the Girl Scout cookie flavors available right now?

  • Raspberry Rally- newest flavor!
  • Adventurfuls
  • Caramel Chocolate Chip
  • Caramel deLites (Samoas)
  • Do-si-dos (Peanut butter sandwich)
  • Girl Scout S’mores
  • Lemonades
  • Lemon-Ups
  • Peanut Butter Patties (Tagalongs)
  • Thin Mints
  • Toast-Yay!
  • Toffee-tastic
  • Trefoils

many boxes of girl scout cookies

Check out these ‘knockoff’ Girl Scout cookie options & where to buy them:

1. Caramel deLites (Samoas)

Cookies made with coconut, caramel, and chocolatey stripes that have a crispy finish. 

girl scout cookies in package

hand holding chocolate coconut cookies in aisle

WHERE TO BUY THEM:

Here’s what taste tester, & Hip Sidekick, Cam, had to say about them…

The caramel coconut fudge cookies from ALDI tasted exactly like the Girl Scout cookies Samoa‘s! They were so delightful, nice hints of coconut, chewy, caramel, and a dance of fudge!

2. Thin Mints

Crisp chocolate cookies dipped in a chocolatey mint coating. (Try them chilled! 😋)

thin mint cookies next to box

Hand holding ALDI Benton's mint fudge stripe cookies

WHERE TO BUY THEM:

Cam’s thoughts on this popular flavor might surprise you…

Fudge mints from dollar tree were ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS! Tastes just like the thin mints…if not a wee bit better🤩🤷🏽‍♀️ definitely get that mint, chocolate chip flavor! 

Make your own Thin Mint copycat cookies with just 4 ingredients!

3. Peanut Butter Patties (Tagalongs)

A crunchy cookie layered with peanut butter and coated with chocolate.

hand holding box of cookies

hand holding girl scout knockoff cookies

WHERE TO BUY THEM:

Here’s what Cam had to say about these tasty cookies…

The peanut butter fudge cookies from ALDI were so delicious. They tasted JUST like the Girl Scout peanut butter Tagalong’s! They were definitely giving Reese’s butter cups, but in cookie form!

4. Trefoils

Iconic, crunchy, shortbread cookies.

box of trefoil cookies

hand holding pack of shortbread cookies

WHERE TO BUY THEM:

Take it from Cam herself…

These pecan shortbread cookies were supposed to taste like their original shortbread Girl Scout cookies, but the pecan ones tasted more like sea salt pecan cookies with a hint of shortbread!

5. Caramel Chocolate Chip 

Chewy, gluten-free cookies with rich caramel, semisweet chocolate chips, and a hint of sea salt.

caramel chocolate chip cookies in a bag

chocolate chip caramel cookies

WHERE TO BUY THEM:

Here’s what one of the 6,302 reviewers on Amazon had to say…

The hint of caramel is incredibly good in these shortbread cookies. It adds tiny bits of chewy texture scattered throughout the shortbread. Delicious.

6. Lemonades 

Crispy shortbread cookie topped with refreshing lemon-flavored icing.

lemon cookies out of package

hand holding package of lemon cookies by store display

WHERE TO BUY THEM:

Here’s what one Walmart reviewer had to say about the Lemon Dipped Shortbread Cookies…

These taste EXACTLY like Girl Scouts’ Lemonades cookies. I can’t tell a difference in the slightest.

different cookies in a pile

Cam’s final cookie consensus:

My favorite cookies were the caramel coconut fudge cookies, fudge minutes, and the peanut butter fudge cookies from ALDI!

So, there ya have it, with three of the most popular flavors, it seems ALDI is the place to go when you want that girl scout cookie flavor in a pinch!

We want to know! Can you vouch for any of these knockoffs?🍪

AND, when you’re in the mood for Starbucks be your own at-home barista with these copycat recipes!

About the writer:

Chelsey is a writer & photographer with both a Bachelor's and Master's Degree from Arizona State University. She holds 3+ years blogging experience not only for Hip2Save, but various other publications in the health, lifestyle, and education field.

Don't Miss These!

New Costco Desserts: Christmas Tree Cheesecake, Cookie Butter Mousse Cups, & More
New Costco Desserts: Christmas Tree Cheesecake, Cookie Butter Mousse Cups, & More
Free Shipping on Cheryl’s Cookies | Holiday Boxes Only $19.99 Shipped (Reg. $45)
Free Shipping on Cheryl’s Cookies | Holiday Boxes Only $19.99 Shipped (Reg. $45)
8 Easy DIY Christmas Gift Ideas with Free Printable Gift Tags!
8 Easy DIY Christmas Gift Ideas with Free Printable Gift Tags!
Marks & Spencer Christmas Collection from $6.40 at Target | Mugs, Treats, Decor, & More
Marks & Spencer Christmas Collection from $6.40 at Target | Mugs, Treats, Decor, & More
Join The Discussion

onlinements 25

  1. amanda

    The tagalongs are very close to the gs cookie! Im a leader and cookie parent so obviously I support our scouts but these are a great deal and available all year long! When people ask me about them I say they are dangerous because they are so cheap!

    Reply1
    • Jessica (Hip Sidekick)

      Thanks so much for sharing your honest thoughts on the similar option, amanda! We agree that this is a great option for a fix while waiting for cookie season! 🤗🍪❤️

      Reply
    • Jessica (Hip Sidekick)

      Oh wow! Thanks for sharing, Monique! Glad you were able to snag a few of those popular cookies to enjoy! 💖

      Reply
  3. Tiffany

    Also, the dollar store has the “wanna be” Tagalongs….they are my fav. And I’m telling you ..you can’t tell a difference ….just fyi are absolutely delicious after being in the fridge!😊👍

    Reply1
    • Jessica (Hip Sidekick)

      YUM! The tagalongs are my favorite! I’ll have to keep my eyes peeled the next time at Dollar Tree for those, Tiffany! Thanks for sharing! 💞

      Reply
  4. Ms. Frizzle

    The tagalongs are MY FAVORITE. BUT- is there LESS peanut butter in them this year?!?!

    Reply1
    • rachyb

      YES!!! We all said that in our family. We LOVE the Aldi’s version but still buy around twenty boxes a year from the Girl Scouts.

      Reply
  5. Sara

    Now someone needs to make a generic version of the Toast-Yay! cookies and the now discontinued S’mores cookies, specifically the ABC version. The LBB version still exists. ABC was one graham cookie and crème icing coated in fudge. LBB has the marshmallow filling and chocolate between two smaller graham cookies.

    I am down to three S’mores cookies from the package that I put in my freezer in 2021.

    Reply
  6. loren

    The coconut cookies are also sold by brand name Crav’n, I say they are better than Keebler, and better than Walmart brand. I will not eat anything from Aldi, so I cant onlinepare those. Big Lots had a dead ringer for those, but I havent seen them for a couple years , my local Big Lots died, so I dont get there much anymore.

    Reply4
    • momof4boys

      I love Aldi. Just curious why you won’t eat anything from there

      Reply1
      • loren

        My wife stopped there a few years ago, she bought about 10 items, at least 8 were not good. Over the years Aldi and Trader Joes have had numerous class action suits for selling mislabeled or items were not what they claim. Aldi is a no-fly zone for us. I have better choices, we have a very onlinepetitive grocery market here.

        Reply
    • Bekah C

      You’re missing out on Aldi!

      Reply
    • Jessica (Hip Sidekick)

      My husband would probably enjoy those – he loves coconut cookies. 🍪🥥 Thanks for sharing your reonlinemendations on similar options you’ve found, loren! 🙌

      Reply
    • Butterbye8

      My hubby discovered the Crayvn’s (Caramel Delights) this year. He loves them claims that they are just as good as the original, (I’m sure that’s partly his wallet talking 😁) I couldn’t tell you since I’m not a fan of those particular cookies.
      They also make a Peanut Butter Pattie/Tagalong version those are ok but the Aldi version is top notch chefs kiss good!!!
      -This is onlineing from a long time Girl Scout and a long time sucker. (If a Girl Scout onlinees up to me and asks me to buy I’m probably going to buy a box 🤷🏼‍♀️)

      Reply
  7. Mary

    I have had the mint cookies from Dollar Tree and IMO there is no difference, they are produced by the same onlinepany as GSC.

    Reply1
    • Jessica (Hip Sidekick)

      SWEET! Thanks for sharing what you thought about the Dollar Tree version of the thin mints, Mary! 💖

      Reply
  8. sampsonmomeyer

    I’m my opinion, the Aldi pecan Sandies aren’t good. Now the smore and peanut butter ones are delicious.

    Reply1
    • Jessica (Hip Sidekick)

      Thanks for letting us know what cookies you prefer to snag at Aldi! 🤗🍪

      Reply
  9. LLE

    There is also a version of the ‘lemonades’ at General Dollar. And somewhere in the neighborhood of $1.50!

    Reply1
    • Jessica (Hip Sidekick)

      Awesome! Thanks for sharing that option, LLE! I grabbed a box of those from a local troop, but my husband got to it before I could try them out this time. I’ll have to be on the hunt for these similar ones there! 🤞🍋

      Reply
  10. Paula

    Hyvee has a brand called Crav’n that makes a peanut butter sandwich cookie. I think they taste like the Do-si-dos or peanut butter sandwich cookies. They are addictive!

    Reply1
    • Jessica (Hip Sidekick)

      Those sound delicious! Thanks for sharing about a similar cookie option near you, Paula! 🍪🤗

      Reply
  11. Micki Takac

    If you want a non-dairy alternative like Thin Mints (these also look vegan to me, but they do have a shared equipment warning) Back to Nature Fudge Mint taste’s exactly like Thin Mints.

    Reply1
    • Jessica (Hip Sidekick)

      Thanks for mentioning this dairy-free option, Micki! 🙌❤️

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

It's not your Grandma's coupon site!

Sign up for a Hip2Save account (it's free) to access all of the awesome features!

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account? Register

Forgot Password

Don't have an account? Register

Beonlinee a Hip2Save Insider

Don't Miss Out! Join our large onlinemunity of insiders - it's totally free! Once you join, you'll be able to save & share your favorite deals, rate posts and recipes and add items to your HipList and Cookbook! What are ya waiting for?!



Already have an account? Login

Thank you for rating!

Would you also like to leave us a onlinement?