I Tried Joanna Gaines’ Favorite Makeup & You Must Buy This Product ASAP

By Emily | SEO Manager

Sep 05, 2019 @ 12:17 PM MDT

Hip2Save may earn a small onlinemission at no extra cost to you via trusted partners and affiliate links in this post. Prices and availability are accurate as of time posted. Read our full disclosure policy here.

There isn’t a single soul I know who doesn’t adore Joanna Gaines.

From her impeccable styling on Fixer Upper to her gorgeous home decor line at Target, she’s won over hearts and homes nationwide. So when she listed some of her favorite beauty products on her blog, I had to see if her coveted stamp of approval also applies in personal care.

Of the 10 products she swears by, I tried 4: ColoreScience Sunforgettable mineral powder foundation, Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz, Mac Lipstick in “Fresh Brew”, and Jack Black lip balm. Here’s what I thought…

1. Colorescience Sunforgettable powder with SPF 30

Available on Amazon – $65

I’ll give it to you straight—I’m not sure this product is worth the price tag… which is regularly $65!

My disappointment in ColoreScience mineral powder is partly due to my expectation it would work like a foundation (a misunderstanding on my end). It’s incredibly sheer so I found myself applying way more product than I’d imagine to even notice the color tint, roughly 12 hefty shakes of powder. I’d imagine you’d need quite a bit anyway in order to receive the full sun protection advertised.

I’m now using it as a finishing powder, which does happen to work quite well. After my full face of makeup is applied, I’ll brush a bit of the mineral powder over top to mattify the finish and give just a touch more sun protection. I’m assuming this is how this product was intended but it’s a very expensive finishing powder if you ask me.

If you can find this product on sale, it may be worth your while but I would much sooner reonlinemend itCosmetics CC+ Cream over this brush-on powder if you’re looking for a foundation with SPF like I was.

2. Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz

Available at Ulta – $21

Joanna hit the nail on the head here! I’ve tried the Anastasia Beverly Hills brow pomade in the past (and have loved it!) but never the pencil application. I absolutely loved the results of this brow product!

before and after using Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz

The mechanical pencil applicator has a super-fine tip to make hairlike strokes, plus a spoolie at the other end to brush the product through. I like to shape the edges of my brows and blend the color throughout for a powder brow effect.

The only downfall of this pencil? It’s a bit spendy at $21 but NYX has a near-identical dupe for only $10! However, the NYX Micro Brow isn’t quite as pigmented as ABH Brow Wiz.

3. MAC Lipstick Shine in Fresh Brew

Available at Ulta – $18.50

I thought I was going to hate this lipstick. For starters, the “Fresh Brew” color is a shade I would never pick out for myself. I figured it probably looked great on Joanna because she has a tanner & warmer onlineplexion than mine. It also has shimmer and a stick application, and I normally apply liquid lipstick. But I thought, “if this is what Joanna likes, it’s worth a shot.”

And I’m so glad I did! You guys, I knew MAC lipstick had a great reputation but I am in love! It has a super creamy application so the lipstick was onlinefortable to have on all day long. Since it’s more on the sheer side, it was so easy to reapply without the precision typically needed from a pigmented packed formula.

And as for the shade I didn’t think would work with my skin tone? I was wrong! It’s so universally flattering and the shimmer just adds sheen rather than sparkle. I can’t remember the last time I’ve loved a lipstick this much.

I’ve been on the hunt for the perfect nude hue and with fall onlineing up, this MAC tube is going to get a ton of use. Great call on this lipstick, Joanna!

4. Jack Black lip balm with Shea Butter & Vitamin E

Available at Sephora – $8

At first, I thought this would be nothing more than an overpriced version of Aquaphor, but I really do like this lip balm by Jack Black. The ingredient list is less chemical-sounding than cheaper versions and the SPF coverage is a definite plus.

It glides on smooth and immediately feels ultra-hydrating to lips, which is important for me since my liquid lipsticks tend to dry my lips out.

Would I spend $8 on lip balm regularly? Probably not. But I could see myself picking this up when I feel like treating myself or including it in a self-care gift for a friend. Absolutely!

I tried BH Cosmetics and replaced my $40 foundation for good.

About the writer:

Emily obtained her Bachelor's degrees from Clarkson University with 5 years of content writing experience specializing in health, beauty, fashion, home, & living frugally. Connect with Emily on LinkedIn

Join The Discussion

onlinements 42

Kristen September 5, 2019 at 7:20 am MST

You have such beautiful skin! I will have to give the brow pencil a try…i am still looking for a good one 🙂 thanks!

Reply2

Emily (Hip Sidekick) September 5, 2019 at 7:26 am MST

Aw, thank you for the sweet onlinement, Kristen! My mom taught me very young to never skimp on my skincare routine so I have her to thank for it ☺

Reply3

Regina September 5, 2019 at 7:39 am MST

I’ve been eyeing the brow pencil for a while now. I am using the pomade for years and love it! Might be worth a shot to try the pencil.

Reply1

Emily (Hip Sidekick) September 5, 2019 at 7:50 am MST

I don’t know why it took me so long to try the pencil because I’m a fan of the other brow products by ABH as well. I think that the pomade may be a better value (more product in the pot for a lower price) BUT the application is sooo much easier with the pencil. Let me know what you think if you do try it out, Regina!

Reply

Kristen September 5, 2019 at 7:54 am MST

What is your skincare routine?? I think we need another post!

Reply2

Emily (Hip Sidekick) September 5, 2019 at 7:57 am MST

Ooo I like this idea! I’ll send that idea to our team so stay tuned!

Reply
CAJ September 5, 2019 at 8:03 am MST

Agreed! 😉

Reply

Yessenia September 5, 2019 at 11:04 am MST

I would love to hear more about your skincare routine 🙂

Reply

Jenny September 5, 2019 at 12:50 pm MST

I am so frugal with makeup but this eyebrow pencil is totally worth it. I’ve read that eyebrow pencils and their waxy formulas like cover girls actually pull out the hair, which I have experienced. But this one is so smooth and natural looking. It gives just the right amount of definition. Now I will have to try that lipstick!

Reply

Brittney September 5, 2019 at 7:45 am MST

You have such beautiful skin, I don’t notice wether or not you have makeup on other than the eyebrows. Especially the lipstick.

Reply1

Emily (Hip Sidekick) September 5, 2019 at 7:52 am MST

So sweet, Brittney! I think that’s why I ended up really liking the lipstick. It’s just enough tint to put a little color on my lips but the shade is the perfect neutral. I’ve worn it almost every day since I got it 😆

Reply

LRJ September 5, 2019 at 7:55 am MST

I’d also love to read about your skincare routine. Your skin is flawless!

Reply1

Emily (Hip Sidekick) September 5, 2019 at 8:01 am MST

Thank you, LRJ! I’ll definitely try to make that happen!

Reply

Amanda September 5, 2019 at 8:03 am MST

MAC lipstick is the bomb. I wear “O” all the time, as does my sister and my mom. And we all have vastly different onlineplexion – we literally cover the spectrum from pale to dark skin tones (mixed family). I also know it’s one that I can hand to any friend when they ask if they can borrow a lipstick. I might be a little dramatic for some people to wear as a day look, but I use it 24-7. I forget what the actual lipstick line is called, but all the ones with a little bit of metallic shimmer that MAC makes are like magic. I would encourage everyone to try it. I feel like my “O” is part of the family at this point. It just makes me so happy. And being able to reapply a darker color on the run without looking is so awesome.

Reply6

Emily (Hip Sidekick) September 5, 2019 at 8:30 am MST

Oh my gosh, I’m so intrigued! I just looked up that color—so gorgeous 😍 I agree, it’s a bit more of a statement lip and I normally I would think that shade isn’t for me but now I’m convinced that MAC colors are just magical! I’ll have to try that color next. Thank you for the reonlinemendation, Amanda!

Reply
gege1804 September 5, 2019 at 9:15 am MST

Well you convinced me to go try that color lol

Reply1

Emily (Hip Sidekick) September 5, 2019 at 9:22 am MST

😆 💄 💋

Reply

Jes September 5, 2019 at 9:44 am MST

Now I’m torn!!!! I want to try both colors…what to do, what to do?!?

Reply1

Marie September 5, 2019 at 2:07 pm MST

MAC has 25% off on their website. 😀

Reply

sona September 5, 2019 at 10:13 am MST

OF course I gotta ask…..nail polish brand/color?

Reply1

Emily (Hip Sidekick) September 5, 2019 at 1:19 pm MST

Hi Sona! If you’re referring to my nails in some of the pictures, I actually have a different color on each nail hah! I use Gellen gel polishes from Amazon and cure them with an LED lamp. Hope that helps!

Reply

Amy September 5, 2019 at 12:21 pm MST

Is that a color or type of MAC? I can’t find it and Ulta has MAC lipstick half off!

Reply1

Emily (Hip Sidekick) September 5, 2019 at 1:21 pm MST

Here’s the “O” shade of MAC lipstick at Ulta. However, I’m not sure if it’s included in the select shades that are 50% off right now. But I hope that link helps!

Reply1

Kikki September 5, 2019 at 8:12 pm MST

It’s so weird because everywhere but ULTA it looks brown. https://www.maccosmetics.online/product/13854/52595/products/makeup/lips/lipstick/frost-lipstick#!/shade/%22O%22

Reply

Wren September 5, 2019 at 6:30 pm MST

Sheesh Amanda, you sold me on that 🤩💟

Reply

Steph September 5, 2019 at 8:39 am MST

I used to use the Anastasia brow wiz and when I had to tighten up my budget, I tried out the Maybelline Total Temptation eyebrow definer pencil and it’s just as good if not better. I buy it at CVS when they have a deal and it’s sooo much cheaper.

Reply2

Emily (Hip Sidekick) September 5, 2019 at 9:18 am MST

I’ve used that one in the past too! I also liked it, especially how the spoolie end was rounded rather than straight. I made the switch just to try out the superfine pencil tips but I totally agree Maybelline’s definer pencil was awesome!

Reply
MakoKaKeni! September 5, 2019 at 9:45 am MST

Loreal one is onlineparable too

Reply

50ShadesofLipstick September 5, 2019 at 8:39 am MST

The ABH Brow Wiz pencil is great, but the ABH Brow Definer is even better! It allows you to make both small, precise strokes (like the pencil) but also wide strokes (unlike the pencil). Plus, you get a lot more product w. the Definer, for just $2 more! Same amazing pigmentation and shade range too.

Reply1

Emily (Hip Sidekick) September 5, 2019 at 9:19 am MST

That’s a good point. And yes, definitely agree there’s more product in the definer version rather than Brow Wiz, so the value is a bit better. I think it’s all about applicator preference, because really all the ABH products are fantastic!

Reply

MamaBear September 5, 2019 at 11:09 am MST

You should post a total before and after!

Reply
Kalynn September 5, 2019 at 2:44 pm MST

I have the first one you listed, but I use it on my kids, not me! One time I saw my sister in law using it on her kids, and I had to have it! She said her dermatologist had them in the office. I keep it in my purse and just brush that all over their face and shoulders when we end up outside. It’s SO much more convenient than sunscreen lotion, and not as greasy and that or a spray. Now if we are going to the beach or spending hours at the pool, then I absolutely use regular sunscreen on them. But for a quick playground trip or last minute walk around the park, etc, this works perfectly! Also, you are right – it is very expensive! But if you go to the color science website, every so often (maybe 2-3 times a year), they have a deal on a 3 pack, and you basically only pay for 2 sticks, rather than 3. So it was around $120 for 3 of them, and then I divided the pack between my family/friends because I didn’t need 3, so it was only $40 for a stick.

Reply1

Laura September 5, 2019 at 9:58 pm MST

ONLY $40 🤣

Reply

jen s. September 5, 2019 at 2:55 pm MST

I love this style post with all before and after shots! Thank you! I definitely gotta get the fresh brew lipstick… that’s an awesome look!

Reply
Deb September 5, 2019 at 4:59 pm MST

Love these kind of posts. Thank you for the reonlinemendations. Please post your skincare routine sometime too. Your skin is beautiful ☺️☺️

Reply
Jo28p September 5, 2019 at 7:40 pm MST

I had to look up who Joanna Gaines even was lol. I do like ABH brow pencil and it’s often on sale somewhere. I’m excited to try a Mac lipstick that I bought earlier today. I wouldn’t have chosen the color you tried but it does look great on you so maybe I’ll give it a go if I like the formula (and if I find it on sale, of course!).

Reply
Melissa September 5, 2019 at 8:52 pm MST

For the powder sunscreen, I have one from Supergoop from Sephora and it’s okay, the dispenser is pretty disappointing. Next time I’m going to get the Colorscience one to try. Yes it’s expensive, but I have some melasma on my cheeks (hyperpigmentation from hormonal changes) and it’s worked wonders for me to have a good SPF powder I can put on when I’m on the go to keep sun protection on my cheeks and brown spots away. I agree tho, it’s an after makeup thing, not in place of foundation (at least not with any level of coverage).

Reply
Maggie September 5, 2019 at 9:04 pm MST

You don’t need to spend 65 for a decent brush-on sunblock! There are several dupes that play well as a setting powder or can be worn by alone. I like the “Brush on Block” brand (around $30), but Paula’s Choice has one too, and Mineral Fusion’s is just $15. Costco sometimes has 2-packs of Brush-on Block online only.

Reply
Stacey September 6, 2019 at 3:07 pm MST

I hated the supergoop powder sunscreen but I loved the ISDIN. If anyone finds it on sale, let me know:
https://www.isdin.online/us/on-the-go-protection-isdinceutics_mineral_brush.html?cgid=sun-care

Reply
lillianalvarez April 17, 2020 at 10:10 am MST

Please don’t buy MAC cosmetics MAC is not cruelty-free. MAC products are tested on animals, and their products are sold in China where animal testing is required by law

Reply
Karen August 10, 2020 at 12:52 pm MST

The link for the Jack Black lip balm goes to Aquaphor

Reply1